Smith.ai answers your phone with trained human receptionists, and Smith.ai pricing is per call, starting at thirty calls a month. Bigly Sales runs a managed AI calling operation priced by the minute in volume plans that start at $99 a month, built to scale from a single line to teams whose phone volume runs into the thousands. The two are not really chasing the same buyer, and the number that decides it is how many calls a month you actually take.
Smith.ai is a genuinely good answer below a few hundred calls a month, and the people answering are people. Bigly becomes the better fit at the point where per-call pricing starts growing faster than the revenue those calls produce. The Smith.ai pricing comparison below shows where that point sits.
The deciding question is volume. A human receptionist service is a fair choice at a few dozen calls a month. Once calls run into the hundreds or thousands, or you also want outbound follow-up, per minute pricing on one platform starts to win clearly.
Bigly charges by the minute in volume plans, so the cost of each conversation falls as volume rises instead of staying flat at a per-call rate.
Bigly runs qualification, aged lead reactivation and follow-up campaigns on the same platform, not only the calls that happen to arrive.
Consent checks, suppression lists, known litigant screening and state calling rules run before a call is placed rather than being reviewed after the fact.
Call outcomes, transcripts and dispositions write back into your CRM and calendar rather than sitting in a separate dashboard, so your team works from the records it already uses.
Smith.ai is a good service, and for some businesses it is the right one.
If every caller must reach a trained person, Smith.ai’s receptionists provide that and Bigly does not.
If you take a few dozen calls a month and only need messages and simple intake, a small per call plan is easy to budget.
If many calls are emotional or delicate, a human receptionist can be the better first voice.
If you never plan to call leads back or run outbound campaigns, an answering service covers what you need.
A prospect calls at 7 p.m. asking about pricing, then does not book. Here is what happens on each service.
| WHAT HAPPENS | BIGLY SALES | SMITH.AI |
|---|---|---|
| Who answers | An AI voice agent with your script and intake questions | A trained human receptionist, or their AI-first option |
| How it is billed | Per minute inside your monthly plan | Per call against a monthly allowance, with overage per extra call |
| Getting the lead to your team | Warm transfer or booked appointment, outcome written to your CRM | Message taking or a transfer per your instructions |
| Following up the next day | Included on the same plan as an outbound follow-up call | Sold as a separate outreach service |
| At 1,000 calls a month | Inside the $500 Prospector plan when calls average three minutes or less | About $8,050 on the Pro plan once overage applies |
Smith.ai figures are from its published plans. Bigly figures are the live plans.
A practical comparison for teams choosing between a human answering service and a managed AI calling operation. Smith.ai figures are their published plans, ours are the live Bigly tiers.
| FEATURE CAPABILITY | BIGLY SALES | SMITH.AI |
|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Teams handling thousands of calls a month | Teams handling tens to a few hundred calls a month |
| Who answers | AI voice agents, with live transfer to your team | Trained human receptionists, with an AI-first option |
| Pricing model | Minutes in volume plans, outbound and inbound alike | Per call, billed against a monthly call allowance |
| Entry price | $99 a month for 500 minutes | $300 a month for 30 calls |
| Effective rate at plan size | About 20 cents a minute on Scout, 8 cents on Rainmaker | About $10 a call on Starter, $7 a call on Pro |
| Cost of 1,000 inbound calls | Inside the $500 Prospector plan when calls average three minutes or less | About $8,050 on the Pro plan once overage applies |
| Outbound campaigns | Included on the same per minute plans as inbound | Sold as a separate outreach service |
| Pre-call compliance screening | Litigant list and state rule checks before the dial | Not stated in their published plans |
| Whitelisted local numbers | More than 200 owned lines with local presence | Not stated in their published plans |
| Contract | Monthly plan sized with an account manager | Month to month, no long-term contract |
Most teams switch when call volume grows or when they want outbound follow-up too.
Tell us how many calls you take, how long they run and what your receptionists do on each one.
Bigly writes the greeting, intake questions and routing, and tests them before going live.
The same plan can call back missed leads, follow up on quotes and reactivate older leads.
Run Bigly on part of your volume for a month and compare cost per handled call with your current invoice.
Bigly Sales handles inbound answering and outbound campaigns on one platform, priced so the cost of each conversation falls as your volume rises. Bring your own call mix and we will size it honestly during a free setup session.
What buyers ask when comparing Bigly Sales and Smith.ai.
Get The Bigly Brief. AI calling tips, product news and what is working in sales. You will only hear from us when we have something worth sharing.
By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Bigly Sales. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy
Watch your inbox for the next Bigly Brief.